Who's overrated in football? The Aura Index

Every player in Europe's top five leagues, hype against output: who's overrated, who's underrated, and the numbers behind every verdict.

The most hyped players

  1. Lamine Yamal (FC Barcelona): Ballon d'Or level
  2. Harry Kane (FC Bayern München): Superstar
  3. Erling Haaland (Manchester City): The real deal
  4. Michael Olise (FC Bayern München): Ballon d'Or level
  5. Raphinha (FC Barcelona): Ballon d'Or level
  6. Kylian Mbappé (Real Madrid): Ballon d'Or level
  7. Arda Güler (Real Madrid): Superstar
  8. Ferran Torres (Paris Saint-Germain): Good but relax
  9. Ousmane Dembélé (Paris Saint-Germain): Superstar
  10. Franco Mastantuono (Fiorentina): Pure hype
  11. Yan Diomande (Real Madrid): The real deal
  12. Lautaro Martínez (Inter): Superstar
  13. Karim Adeyemi (FC Barcelona): The real deal
  14. Rodri (FC Barcelona): Superstar
  15. Pedri (FC Barcelona): The real deal
  16. Enzo Fernández (Manchester City): Good but relax
  17. Rayan Cherki (Manchester City): Superstar
  18. Antoine Semenyo (Manchester City): Good but relax
  19. Nico Paz (Como): Worth the hype
  20. Pau Cubarsí (FC Barcelona): The real deal
  21. Morgan Rogers (Chelsea): Good but relax
  22. Jérémy Jacquet (Liverpool FC): Worth the hype
  23. Carlos Espí (Real Madrid): Early days
  24. Marquinhos (Paris Saint-Germain): Superstar
  25. Jude Bellingham (Real Madrid): The real deal
  26. Alexander Isak (Liverpool FC): Good but relax
  27. Khvicha Kvaratskhelia (Paris Saint-Germain): Worth the hype
  28. Jonathan David (Atlético Madrid): Worth the hype
  29. Désiré Doué (Paris Saint-Germain): Worth the hype
  30. Bukayo Saka (Arsenal): Worth the hype
  31. Dani Olmo (FC Barcelona): Superstar
  32. Jamal Musiala (FC Bayern München): Early days
  33. Alejandro Grimaldo (Atlético Madrid): Superstar
  34. Kevin De Bruyne (SSC Napoli): Worth the hype
  35. Ismael Saibari (FC Bayern München): Worth the hype
  36. Martin Ødegaard (Arsenal): Good but relax
  37. João Cancelo (FC Barcelona): Worth the hype
  38. David Raya (Arsenal): Worth the hype
  39. Kerim Alajbegović (Juventus): Overrated
  40. Brian Brobbey (Sunderland): Pure hype
  41. Vinícius Júnior (Real Madrid): Worth the hype
  42. Xavi Espart (FC Barcelona): The real deal
  43. Fermín López (FC Barcelona): Superstar
  44. Dominik Szoboszlai (Liverpool FC): Good but relax
  45. Gabriel Jesus (FC Barcelona): Worth the hype
  46. Paulo Dybala (AS Roma): Superstar
  47. Cole Palmer (Chelsea): Worth the hype
  48. Adrien Rabiot (AC Milan): The real deal
  49. Zion Suzuki (Aston Villa): Good but relax
  50. Thibaut Courtois (Real Madrid): Overrated
  51. Joshua Kimmich (FC Bayern München): Ballon d'Or level
  52. Johan Manzambi (Aston Villa): The real deal
  53. Jobe Bellingham (Borussia Dortmund): Overrated
  54. Anthony Gordon (FC Barcelona): Worth the hype
  55. Bernardo Silva (Real Madrid): Pure hype
  56. Antony (Real Betis): Overrated
  57. Manu Koné (AS Roma): Priced right
  58. Donyell Malen (AS Roma): Superstar
  59. Nicolas Jackson (Aston Villa): Worth the hype
  60. Kenan Yıldız (Juventus): Early days

Clubs

Premier League

LaLiga

Bundesliga

Serie A

Ligue 1

Stat leaderboards

Best centre-backs

Best midfielders

Best full-backs

Best keepers

Best strikers

Best wingers and 10s